Siamamulets - Theravada Buddhism & Thai Amulets Online Discussion Forum  

Go Back   Siamamulets - Theravada Buddhism & Thai Amulets Online Discussion Forum > Archives Folders > Amulet Identification > Genuine and Fake

Notices

Genuine and Fake พระเครื่องของแท้และของปลอม - The section created purely for sharing on comparison between known genuine and fake amulets. Please do not ask regarding authenticity questions.

Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
Old 13-10-2009, 13:01   #1
ken Yeo
Supreme Member

 
ken Yeo's Avatar
 
Join Date: 06 Sep 2008
Posts: 7,245
Thanks: 0
Thanked 1 Time in 1 Post
Karma Reputation Points: 1406 : ken Yeo is a name known to allken Yeo is a name known to allken Yeo is a name known to allken Yeo is a name known to allken Yeo is a name known to allken Yeo is a name known to allken Yeo is a name known to allken Yeo is a name known to allken Yeo is a name known to allken Yeo is a name known to all
Rep Power: 11

Awards Showcase
3rd placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 3rd placing 1st placing 3rd placing 3rd placing 3rd placing 1st placing 3rd placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 4th placing 1st placing 1st placing 3rd placing 1st placing 3rd placing 2nd placing 1st placing 1st placing 4th placing 1st placing 2nd placing 3rd placing 3rd placing 4th placing 4th placing 1st placing 1st placing 4th placing 2nd placing 1st placing 1st placing 3rd placing 3rd placing 3rd placing 4th placing 3rd placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 1st placing 4th placing 1st placing 2nd placing 1st placing 3rd placing 3rd placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 4th placing 4th placing 1st placing 2nd placing 1st placing 2nd placing 4th placing 2nd placing 3rd placing 2nd placing 1st placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 4th placing 2nd placing 1st placing 1st placing 2nd placing 1st placing 3rd placing 1st placing 3rd placing 1st placing 2nd placing 1st placing 4th placing 3rd placing 1st placing 3rd placing 3rd placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 4th placing 3rd placing 2nd placing 1st placing 3rd placing 2nd placing 1st placing 1st placing 4th placing 3rd placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 1st placing 1st placing 4th placing 2nd placing 4th placing 3rd placing 3rd placing 1st placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 3rd placing 3rd placing 2nd placing 4th placing 4th placing 4th placing 4th placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 3rd placing 2nd placing 4th placing 4th placing 4th placing 1st placing 1st placing 2nd placing 4th placing 3rd placing 2nd placing 1st placing 1st placing 1st placing 1st placing 1st placing 1st placing 1st placing 1st placing 4th placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 1st placing 1st placing 1st placing 1st placing 1st placing 1st placing 1st placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 1st placing 1st placing 1st placing 1st placing 1st placing 1st placing 1st placing 1st placing 1st placing 1st placing 2nd placing 3rd placing 1st placing 2nd placing 1st placing 1st placing 1st placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 3rd placing 3rd placing 3rd placing 3rd placing 2nd placing 3rd placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 1st placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 4th placing 4th placing 3rd placing 2nd placing 4th placing 1st placing 1st placing 2nd placing 3rd placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 3rd placing 4th placing 1st placing 1st placing 1st placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 4th placing 4th placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 1st placing 3rd placing 1st placing 3rd placing 2nd placing 3rd placing 2nd placing 4th placing 3rd placing 2nd placing 
Total Awards: 214

Default CKN 2513 Genuine & Fake

Just for sharing.......
2513 CKN Wat Teap Sirim


Genuine




Fake


Last edited by ken Yeo; 13-10-2009 at 13:05.
ken Yeo is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 13-10-2009, 13:51   #2
Donny
Certified Member


 
Donny's Avatar
 
Join Date: 14 Jan 2008
Location: Tampines
Posts: 857
Thanks: 0
Thanked 1 Time in 1 Post
Karma Reputation Points: 735 : Donny is a famous personalityDonny is a famous personalityDonny is a famous personalityDonny is a famous personalityDonny is a famous personalityDonny is a famous personalityDonny is a famous personality
Rep Power: 11

Awards Showcase
4th placing 1st placing 3rd placing 1st placing 3rd placing 1st placing 2nd placing 
Total Awards: 7

Default

thanks for sharing. but the 1st one is real? how do you tell?
Donny is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 13-10-2009, 14:58   #3
ken Yeo
Supreme Member

 
ken Yeo's Avatar
 
Join Date: 06 Sep 2008
Posts: 7,245
Thanks: 0
Thanked 1 Time in 1 Post
Karma Reputation Points: 1406 : ken Yeo is a name known to allken Yeo is a name known to allken Yeo is a name known to allken Yeo is a name known to allken Yeo is a name known to allken Yeo is a name known to allken Yeo is a name known to allken Yeo is a name known to allken Yeo is a name known to allken Yeo is a name known to all
Rep Power: 11

Awards Showcase
3rd placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 3rd placing 1st placing 3rd placing 3rd placing 3rd placing 1st placing 3rd placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 4th placing 1st placing 1st placing 3rd placing 1st placing 3rd placing 2nd placing 1st placing 1st placing 4th placing 1st placing 2nd placing 3rd placing 3rd placing 4th placing 4th placing 1st placing 1st placing 4th placing 2nd placing 1st placing 1st placing 3rd placing 3rd placing 3rd placing 4th placing 3rd placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 1st placing 4th placing 1st placing 2nd placing 1st placing 3rd placing 3rd placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 4th placing 4th placing 1st placing 2nd placing 1st placing 2nd placing 4th placing 2nd placing 3rd placing 2nd placing 1st placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 4th placing 2nd placing 1st placing 1st placing 2nd placing 1st placing 3rd placing 1st placing 3rd placing 1st placing 2nd placing 1st placing 4th placing 3rd placing 1st placing 3rd placing 3rd placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 4th placing 3rd placing 2nd placing 1st placing 3rd placing 2nd placing 1st placing 1st placing 4th placing 3rd placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 1st placing 1st placing 4th placing 2nd placing 4th placing 3rd placing 3rd placing 1st placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 3rd placing 3rd placing 2nd placing 4th placing 4th placing 4th placing 4th placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 3rd placing 2nd placing 4th placing 4th placing 4th placing 1st placing 1st placing 2nd placing 4th placing 3rd placing 2nd placing 1st placing 1st placing 1st placing 1st placing 1st placing 1st placing 1st placing 1st placing 4th placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 1st placing 1st placing 1st placing 1st placing 1st placing 1st placing 1st placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 1st placing 1st placing 1st placing 1st placing 1st placing 1st placing 1st placing 1st placing 1st placing 1st placing 2nd placing 3rd placing 1st placing 2nd placing 1st placing 1st placing 1st placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 3rd placing 3rd placing 3rd placing 3rd placing 2nd placing 3rd placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 1st placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 4th placing 4th placing 3rd placing 2nd placing 4th placing 1st placing 1st placing 2nd placing 3rd placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 3rd placing 4th placing 1st placing 1st placing 1st placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 4th placing 4th placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 1st placing 3rd placing 1st placing 3rd placing 2nd placing 3rd placing 2nd placing 4th placing 3rd placing 2nd placing 
Total Awards: 214

Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Donny View Post
thanks for sharing. but the 1st one is real? how do you tell?
sorry brother, I might need to post more photo, wait i go back to take more photo and re post one more time.

actually the seller told me 2nd one was make by wat niwat, but i go to find out CKN this phim is just only make by Wat Teap Sirim.
ken Yeo is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 14-10-2009, 09:22   #4
Tuborg
Junior Member
 
Tuborg's Avatar
 
Join Date: 15 Aug 2009
Posts: 204
Thanks: 0
Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts
Karma Reputation Points: 115 : Tuborg has many friendsTuborg has many friends
Rep Power: 10
Default

I think there should be a logical approach to distinguish fake from real so that it leaves no doubt in the mind of the reader otherwise it only leads to confusing the readers.
Tuborg is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 14-10-2009, 11:57   #5
loboking
New Member
 
Join Date: 19 Jul 2007
Posts: 23
Thanks: 0
Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts
Karma Reputation Points: 32 : loboking is getting along well with others
Rep Power: 12
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by ken Yeo View Post
Just for sharing.......
2513 CKN Wat Teap Sirim


Genuine




Fake

the 2nd picture is not fake to me, can you retake the pic of the under base?
loboking is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 14-10-2009, 12:12   #6
Somdej
Super Administrator
 
Somdej's Avatar
 
Join Date: 06 Feb 2006
Location: Yishun
Posts: 235,481
Thanks: 4
Thanked 35 Times in 15 Posts
Karma Reputation Points: 8964 : Somdej has a reputation beyond reputeSomdej has a reputation beyond reputeSomdej has a reputation beyond reputeSomdej has a reputation beyond reputeSomdej has a reputation beyond reputeSomdej has a reputation beyond reputeSomdej has a reputation beyond reputeSomdej has a reputation beyond reputeSomdej has a reputation beyond reputeSomdej has a reputation beyond reputeSomdej has a reputation beyond repute
Rep Power: 41
Visit Somdej's Facebook
Default

Ken,

This section pave the way for us to share differences of authenticity of amulets but we will appreciate if you can provide enough substantial materials to aid in your sharing.

With detailed drawn up of identification critical points or explanation with words or even a video will help. Its up to you, I think with just 2 pictures being posted up, no one is able to grasp anything.
Somdej is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 18-10-2009, 17:59   #7
winning888
Junior Member
 
winning888's Avatar
 
Join Date: 01 Apr 2009
Posts: 460
Thanks: 0
Thanked 2 Times in 2 Posts
Karma Reputation Points: 288 : winning888 is well received in the communitywinning888 is well received in the communitywinning888 is well received in the community
Rep Power: 10
Default

Yes,.. please add some valuable information bro ken..
winning888 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 24-11-2009, 12:32   #8
ken Yeo
Supreme Member

 
ken Yeo's Avatar
 
Join Date: 06 Sep 2008
Posts: 7,245
Thanks: 0
Thanked 1 Time in 1 Post
Karma Reputation Points: 1406 : ken Yeo is a name known to allken Yeo is a name known to allken Yeo is a name known to allken Yeo is a name known to allken Yeo is a name known to allken Yeo is a name known to allken Yeo is a name known to allken Yeo is a name known to allken Yeo is a name known to allken Yeo is a name known to all
Rep Power: 11

Awards Showcase
3rd placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 3rd placing 1st placing 3rd placing 3rd placing 3rd placing 1st placing 3rd placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 4th placing 1st placing 1st placing 3rd placing 1st placing 3rd placing 2nd placing 1st placing 1st placing 4th placing 1st placing 2nd placing 3rd placing 3rd placing 4th placing 4th placing 1st placing 1st placing 4th placing 2nd placing 1st placing 1st placing 3rd placing 3rd placing 3rd placing 4th placing 3rd placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 1st placing 4th placing 1st placing 2nd placing 1st placing 3rd placing 3rd placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 4th placing 4th placing 1st placing 2nd placing 1st placing 2nd placing 4th placing 2nd placing 3rd placing 2nd placing 1st placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 4th placing 2nd placing 1st placing 1st placing 2nd placing 1st placing 3rd placing 1st placing 3rd placing 1st placing 2nd placing 1st placing 4th placing 3rd placing 1st placing 3rd placing 3rd placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 4th placing 3rd placing 2nd placing 1st placing 3rd placing 2nd placing 1st placing 1st placing 4th placing 3rd placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 1st placing 1st placing 4th placing 2nd placing 4th placing 3rd placing 3rd placing 1st placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 3rd placing 3rd placing 2nd placing 4th placing 4th placing 4th placing 4th placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 3rd placing 2nd placing 4th placing 4th placing 4th placing 1st placing 1st placing 2nd placing 4th placing 3rd placing 2nd placing 1st placing 1st placing 1st placing 1st placing 1st placing 1st placing 1st placing 1st placing 4th placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 1st placing 1st placing 1st placing 1st placing 1st placing 1st placing 1st placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 1st placing 1st placing 1st placing 1st placing 1st placing 1st placing 1st placing 1st placing 1st placing 1st placing 2nd placing 3rd placing 1st placing 2nd placing 1st placing 1st placing 1st placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 3rd placing 3rd placing 3rd placing 3rd placing 2nd placing 3rd placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 1st placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 4th placing 4th placing 3rd placing 2nd placing 4th placing 1st placing 1st placing 2nd placing 3rd placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 3rd placing 4th placing 1st placing 1st placing 1st placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 4th placing 4th placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 1st placing 3rd placing 1st placing 3rd placing 2nd placing 3rd placing 2nd placing 4th placing 3rd placing 2nd placing 
Total Awards: 214

Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by winning888 View Post
Yes,.. please add some valuable information bro ken..
Ok.... well because I busy at this moment. I will take more photo and re-post this for all brother....

Last edited by ken Yeo; 24-11-2009 at 12:35.
ken Yeo is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 01-12-2009, 12:03   #9
ken Yeo
Supreme Member

 
ken Yeo's Avatar
 
Join Date: 06 Sep 2008
Posts: 7,245
Thanks: 0
Thanked 1 Time in 1 Post
Karma Reputation Points: 1406 : ken Yeo is a name known to allken Yeo is a name known to allken Yeo is a name known to allken Yeo is a name known to allken Yeo is a name known to allken Yeo is a name known to allken Yeo is a name known to allken Yeo is a name known to allken Yeo is a name known to allken Yeo is a name known to all
Rep Power: 11

Awards Showcase
3rd placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 3rd placing 1st placing 3rd placing 3rd placing 3rd placing 1st placing 3rd placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 4th placing 1st placing 1st placing 3rd placing 1st placing 3rd placing 2nd placing 1st placing 1st placing 4th placing 1st placing 2nd placing 3rd placing 3rd placing 4th placing 4th placing 1st placing 1st placing 4th placing 2nd placing 1st placing 1st placing 3rd placing 3rd placing 3rd placing 4th placing 3rd placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 1st placing 4th placing 1st placing 2nd placing 1st placing 3rd placing 3rd placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 4th placing 4th placing 1st placing 2nd placing 1st placing 2nd placing 4th placing 2nd placing 3rd placing 2nd placing 1st placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 4th placing 2nd placing 1st placing 1st placing 2nd placing 1st placing 3rd placing 1st placing 3rd placing 1st placing 2nd placing 1st placing 4th placing 3rd placing 1st placing 3rd placing 3rd placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 4th placing 3rd placing 2nd placing 1st placing 3rd placing 2nd placing 1st placing 1st placing 4th placing 3rd placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 1st placing 1st placing 4th placing 2nd placing 4th placing 3rd placing 3rd placing 1st placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 3rd placing 3rd placing 2nd placing 4th placing 4th placing 4th placing 4th placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 3rd placing 2nd placing 4th placing 4th placing 4th placing 1st placing 1st placing 2nd placing 4th placing 3rd placing 2nd placing 1st placing 1st placing 1st placing 1st placing 1st placing 1st placing 1st placing 1st placing 4th placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 1st placing 1st placing 1st placing 1st placing 1st placing 1st placing 1st placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 1st placing 1st placing 1st placing 1st placing 1st placing 1st placing 1st placing 1st placing 1st placing 1st placing 2nd placing 3rd placing 1st placing 2nd placing 1st placing 1st placing 1st placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 3rd placing 3rd placing 3rd placing 3rd placing 2nd placing 3rd placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 1st placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 4th placing 4th placing 3rd placing 2nd placing 4th placing 1st placing 1st placing 2nd placing 3rd placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 3rd placing 4th placing 1st placing 1st placing 1st placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 4th placing 4th placing 2nd placing 2nd placing 1st placing 3rd placing 1st placing 3rd placing 2nd placing 3rd placing 2nd placing 4th placing 3rd placing 2nd placing 
Total Awards: 214

Default

I just want to sharing, CKN 2513

left fake..............Right Genuine
The material for genuine is dry powder but fake one material powder with oil




We can see the chop for Genuine one is deep



Genuine I just send to atten competition to confirm at Pantid 22/11/09. not prize because the condition not so good..........

ken Yeo is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 28-11-2010, 00:22   #10
trapeze
New Member
 
Join Date: 08 Nov 2010
Location: Penang
Posts: 11
Thanks: 0
Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts
Karma Reputation Points: 16 : trapeze is neutral, pH7
Rep Power: 0
Default

Is this a very small piece? I got 1 from Wat Thepsirin some time last year, would it be fake as the chop is not deep? even though i got it from the LP at CK Nor Wat?
trapeze is offline   Reply With Quote
Reply

Tags
111, amulets, authenticity, back, competition, cute, fake, good, identification, ken yeo, love, wat, winning888


Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)
 
Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump


All times are GMT +8. The time now is 13:32.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.3
Copyright ©2000 - 2018, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright @ siamamulets.com (2006-2018)